Reverse
Exchanges: The Benefits and The Process
Kevin L. Kete
, SIOR-North Star Deferred Exchange
We
often hear that the three most important things in real estate are
location, location and location. The three most important things in a
Section 1031 tax deferred exchange might well be timing, timing and
timing. Utilizing a reverse exchange allows an investor maximum
flexibility, avoids time pressures and achieves significant tax savings.
It puts the investor in control of timing issues…a strategy to save,
make or optimize a transaction.
In
practice it is the ultimate legal fiction, provided for by Revenue
Procedure 2000-37 which established a ‘safe harbor’ process to
effect a reverse exchange outcome. The process is not the reciprocal of
the forward or delayed exchange. Rather, it consists of two separate
components which are contractually integrated and then results in a
reverse exchange outcome.
More
accurately it is a “parking” transaction which is then followed by a
regular Section 1031 tax deferred exchange.
Why
park it? The investor for
any number of reasons needs, or wants, to acquire a new or replacement
property before having sold an existing or relinquished property AND
needs, or wants, all the proceeds from the sale of that relinquished
property to acquire the new property including all the dollars which
otherwise would have to be paid in capital gain, recapture and state
taxes. Some of theses reasons include:
| · |
The
investor wants to “seize the moment” and not lose an ideal
replacement property |
| · |
The
buyer for the investor’s relinquished property is unwilling or
unable to close on it in a timely manner and the seller of the
replacement property is unwilling or unable to wait |
| · |
The
investor’s relinquished property may not be listed or it may
be listed but not under contract or it may be under contract but
the closing date is too far out |
| · |
If the
closings on the sales of multiple relinquished properties
cannot be co-coordinated in time to exchange all of them into
a replacement property or properties, then park a portion
of the replacement property or properties until the rest of the
relinquished property sales are concluded |
| · |
Avoid
the 45 day Identification Period “stress test”. If the
investor is comfortable
that its relinquished property will be sold at an attractive
price in a timely manner, put off selling the it until a
suitable replacement property is put under contract to avoid having
the 45/180 deadlines and keeping the investor from losing
negotiating leverage |
The
first component, is parking ( or “warehousing” ) the replacement
property with what the IRS refers to as an Exchange Accommodation
Titleholder, or EAT, which takes title to the replacement property on
behalf of the investor for up to 180 days.
The
investor enters into a Qualified Exchange Accommodation Agreement, an
QEAA, with an EAT such as North Star, which uses funds lent to it by the
investor and /or the investor’s lender to purchase and park the
replacement property…essentially just holding title to it.
The
investor is protected by having a Purchase / Sale Agreement with the EAT
requiring the investor to buy and the EAT to sell the parked property at
the original purchase price no later than 180 days from the date the
property was parked. The Eat will also sign a note and mortgage in favor
of the investor to secure the funds that the investor put into the
transaction.
Upon
the subsequent sale of the relinquished property, which must be within
180 days, the proceeds are then used by the investor in the second
component, setting up a regular Section 1031 tax deferred exchange. The
investor identifies the parked property as the replacement property and
proceeds to buy it back from the EAT using the funds from the sale of
the relinquished property being held in the exchange account. The EAT
then uses these same funds to repay the “loan” made to it by the
investor or investor’s lender…what goes around, comes around !
While
the “parked “ property is being
held by the EAT, the investor will lease it from the EAT ( at a no
dollar rental rate) and then may occupy it, sublease it to the tenants,
rent to new tenants, provide property or construction management
services and, except for taking depreciation, will enjoy all the
benefits and burdens of ownership of the parked property.
So,
don’t over look the advantage in considering a reverse exchange to
take control of the timing challenges inherent in “swapping’
property ; deferring tax liabilities which can be used instead to
leverage into a more attractive investment, whether it be another
residential, commercial or TIC deal.
|